Access over private property-public property interest vs private rights

Luxton Nicola

Executive Summary

The exercise of private property rights is increasingly subject to restrictions by legislation and regulation in the wider public interest. Particularly in New Zealand, environmental and resource management law has become integral to, and a major influence upon, the allocation and exercise of real property rights” (Grinlinton, 1995). The current debate about the adequacy (or otherwise) of walking access in the New Zealand outdoors and the potential provision of public access over private land, raises questions about a further restriction on private property rights. The further qualification of rights of property through (potentially) legislation, inevitably results in tension between two competing ideologies; private property and the public interest. This project seeks to discuss the current access debate in the context of those competing sets of values and to stimulate the reader’s thinking about the value and basis of the debate. Firstly, the current access debate is outlined, followed by a discussion of the concept of private property rights, the conflict between public and private interest and differing perspectives of infringements on those rights. Potential issues for farmers arising from increased public access over private land are then set out. The project concludes by questioning the wider motives behind the access debate within the political context.

Grow. Advance. Lead.

Do the Kellogg Rural Leadership Programme.

More Kellogg reports:

2024

Can we add value to non-replacement calves?

The management of non-replacement calves, or bobby calves, is a constant challenge for the NZ Dairy industry. This report investigates potential options for reducing bobby ...
Read More →
Turning skills into profit: How do we grow profitable dairy farmers? 2024

Turning skills into profit: How do we grow profitable dairy farmers?

This research paper aims to identify the key skills that drive profitability in NZ's dairy farming sector and explore how targeted training and development can ...
Read More →
2025

Guardians or Executioners – Navigating the Ethics of Deer Control

Phil’s report examines the expanding deer population across Aotearoa New Zealand, its ecological and economic impacts, the limitations of current management, and the ethical tensions ...
Read More →